Author Topic: Many happy returns  (Read 4533 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Warren Toda

  • Administrator
  • Toronto
  • Posts: 2024
    • www.warrentoda.com
    • Email
Many happy returns
« on: October 26, 2011, 01:11 AM »
It's a busy time for those who like birthday cake and balloons:

October 17 - Saskatoon StarPhoenix turned 109.

October 27 - National Post turns 13.

November 1 - Toronto Sun turns 40.

November 2 - CBC turns 75.

November 3 - Toronto Star turns 119.

November 11 - Edmonton Journal will turn 108.



If you owned a newspaper, would you be proud of that? Assuming the answer is "yes", why wouldn't you put an "About Us" page on your web site to tell the history of your paper? Maybe even hire some kind of reporter to write it.

If you did publish an About Us page, would you hire a photographer to do a few pictures for it? If by bizarre chance, you happened to own a photo archive, would you bother to look through it to find a useful picture or two?

If your newspaper is super-trendy and you have an About Us video, why in the world would it start with a commercial, especially a commercial for a US business?

If your newspaper had a birthday, would you make a big deal of it? Would you at least mention it on your own "Announcements" page? Why do businesses such as furniture stores, car dealerships and restaurants make a big deal of their birthday each year? What do they know that newspapers haven't a clue about?

An About Us page should not be used for making a sales pitch to advertisers. Rather, it's for making a sales pitch to readers: "We want you to share in our history and that of our city. We want you to know something about our newspaper."
 
A successful business knows that the About Us page is actually a misnomer. It's really the "About You, the customer" page. The business takes the time to interest its customers by telling a unique story, a story that helps the customers get to know the personal side of that business.

Once a reader considers the newspaper to be a friend or at least an expected part of their day, then that reader will make many happy returns.




(End of yet another rant from the "What are they thinking?!" collection.)



Photographer in Toronto
info@warrentoda.com

Codie McLachlan

  • Guest
  • Posts:
Re: Many happy returns
« Reply #1 on: November 01, 2011, 01:10 PM »
The Toronto Sun (and it's counterparts) ran this online today: http://www.edmontonsun.com/2011/10/31/happy-birthday-to-the-sun
I haven't seen the print edition yet, though.



Offline Warren Toda

  • Administrator
  • Toronto
  • Posts: 2024
    • www.warrentoda.com
    • Email
Re: Many happy returns
« Reply #2 on: February 11, 2012, 03:54 AM »
Half a birthday wish to the Vancouver Sun for its half-hearted attempt at its 100-year anniversary web pages. The paper celebrates its 100-year anniversary on February 12.

Being in a festive(?) mood, the Sun has put up a confused mess of sort-of 100-year-old web pages. Sadly, they didn't hire the good page designers.

One of the lead stories is about the Titanic sinking, "4 hours ago" on February 10, 2012. All other "100-year-old" stories are similarly misdated.

Wonderful opportunity lost, again.

How often does a business mark a 100-year anniversary? Without a calculator handy, I can only guess that it might happen once every 100 years or so.

So why not make it special?

Why not do something out of the ordinary? Why not do something unexpected?

Why not surprise the readers?

Hey I know, let's change the masthead and call it a day.


• Why not create a special micro-site? What's so special about the anniversary pages being identical to the rest of the site?

• The original paper was 24 pages. Why wasn't at least the front page reproduced, actual size, online?

• Why is the web site background a boring white and not a 3-D antique paper look?

• Why not use an older-looking font? (Hint: look at a copy of the 100-year-old paper).

• Why not re-create some 1912 pictures.

• For the 100-year-old news, why not script the time and date to offset by -100 years? If that couldn't be figured out then don't publish server time/date.

• Get rid of the utterly stupid auto-links to the totally irrelevant third-party web sites. A link to "Pippa's bum"?!?

• Get rid of all the distracting junk on the pages. Why destroy the effect?

• Kinda cool having a travel ad right next to a picture and story of the Titanic sinking. That should really boost business for the travel agency.



How much pre-notice was there that the 100th anniversary was coming? A couple of days notice? Maybe a few weeks? Maybe a few years?

So, why not work with advertisers to create "old" ads? Make advertisers part of the fun. Making advertisers part of the celebration will only strengthen the ties between paper and advertiser. But who wants that?



And most of all, why not make the readers part of the fun? Remember them??

Giving a few readers a free cupcake doesn't sound like too much fun.


It's too late now but:

• Make up some sort of contest with a "100" theme and give a $100 bill to each of the 100 winners, (lay-off a reporter to cover the cost  :D ).

• Get the BC Lions to give away 100 season passes (or are all the seats sold out?).

• Have a contest to win a car for the 1912 price or for $100.

• Get kids involved: who can read aloud 100 words the fastest? Perhaps create some special 100-word news stories that can be read aloud. Of course, this might risk getting lots of TV coverage and who wants that?

• 100 passes to the zoo, the museum, the whatever-else-exists-in-Vancouver. 100 transit passes. 100 free pizzas. Go out and twist every advertiser's arm.

• Sunshine Girls dressed in 1912 swimwear. Oops sorry, wrong Sun.  :D

• Free lunch for every 100-year-old person in town. Would hate to set a world record for having the most 100-year-olds in a room.

• Each school sets up a team of 100 students. The team that does the best one-day community service project wins free pizza lunch for a week (or whatever). (Example: teams clean up a park; help at a food bank, etc.) Of course, it'll be a tie and every team wins.

• Walking tours of Vancouver's historical sites. Bring your camera!

• Get readers to send in their favourite Vancouver memory from the past 100 years. (warning: this may create a ton of new story ideas for the paper, and who wants that to happen?)

• Get readers to write about the most important reason why they live in Vancouver (warning: this may create a ton of new story ideas for the paper, and no one wants that.)

• Get readers to describe what they want in Vancouver in the next 100 years.

• Find a few interesting families with a traceable 100-year (or longer) history in Vancouver.

• How many advertisers in the 1912 paper still exist today?



A little imagination goes a long way toward winning (and keeping) customers.

But then, who wants that?


==============

Added:

Here's how to do a 100th anniversary.

LL Bean is celebrating its 100-year anniversary: special web site, special blog, lots of giveaways, lots of stuff for customers to do (no purchase necessary), opportunities for customers to send in their stories, re-creation of 100-year-old pictures.

Sure, LL Bean has far more money than any newspaper but they sell to an international audience. Everything that store is doing can easily be done on a smaller budget for a local audience,


« Last Edit: February 11, 2012, 08:00 PM by Warren Toda »

Photographer in Toronto
info@warrentoda.com

Offline Ken Gigliotti

  • Retired Professional
  • Posts: 353
    • Email
Re: Many happy returns
« Reply #3 on: February 11, 2012, 10:58 PM »
seriously , how many 100 year olds you know  give a Shxx=t .- sorry, in this business too long i guess - Wpg Free Press 139 years old .We got cake.



Colin Corneau

  • Guest
  • Posts:
Re: Many happy returns
« Reply #4 on: February 12, 2012, 10:45 AM »
Our paper recently turned 130.

We had a funny graphic on the front page banner, and an editor wrote a short story.

Err...that's it.



Offline Ken Gigliotti

  • Retired Professional
  • Posts: 353
    • Email
Re: Many happy returns
« Reply #5 on: February 12, 2012, 12:40 PM »
It started with an online post , then someone ordered a very big cake , then faultly math  . The photogs didn't get any cake because we were out working , maybe cake at 140 . The ownership hasn't been around that long for most papers  , might be a problem

« Last Edit: February 12, 2012, 12:42 PM by Ken Gigliotti »


Offline Warren Toda

  • Administrator
  • Toronto
  • Posts: 2024
    • www.warrentoda.com
    • Email
Re: Many happy returns
« Reply #6 on: March 06, 2012, 04:41 PM »
Quote from: Ken Gigliotti
The photogs didn't get any cake because we were out working...

It's amazing how often that happens. Office brings in food, champagne, cake, whatever ..... oops, we forgot all about the photographers ....


And speaking of no cake, Toronto newspapers didn't bother to mark today's birthday for the country's largest city .... what's its name? .... oh yeah, Toronto. Another marketing opportunity lost.


Photographer in Toronto
info@warrentoda.com

Offline Stacey Newman

  • Professional
  • Milton, ON
  • Posts: 27
    • Stacey Newman Photographer & Writer
    • Email
Re: Many happy returns
« Reply #7 on: March 06, 2012, 04:51 PM »
The Toronto Star had a piece on the city's 175th birthday today http://www.thestar.com/opinion/article/597353--toronto-marks-175th-birthday. No photos online of Toronto over the years. Not sure about the print edition.


Stacey Newman
Commercial & Editorial Photographer
www.staceynewmanphotography.com
Cell: (289) 971-1033
Twitter: @staceylnewman
Facebook: www.facebook.com/StaceyNewmanPhotography

Francis Vachon

  • Guest
  • Posts:
Re: Many happy returns
« Reply #8 on: March 06, 2012, 05:38 PM »
And North America's Oldest Newspaper?

Chronicle-Telegraph will turn 248 on June 21, 2012!
http://www.qctonline.com/history



Offline Jack Simpson

  • Retired Professional
  • Posts: 698
    • Email
Re: Many happy returns
« Reply #9 on: March 08, 2012, 10:51 AM »
And North America's Oldest Newspaper?

Chronicle-Telegraph will turn 248 on June 21, 2012!
http://www.qctonline.com/history

and they went digital and online whilst celebrating their
247th birthday  :o ..
.
.
.
.
... I'm kidding  ;D

jack



Offline Warren Toda

  • Administrator
  • Toronto
  • Posts: 2024
    • www.warrentoda.com
    • Email
Re: Many happy returns
« Reply #10 on: July 09, 2012, 01:55 AM »
A few days late but on July 2nd, P.E.I.'s The Guardian celebrated its 125th anniversary. (Sadly, nothing worth linking to).


Photographer in Toronto
info@warrentoda.com

Offline Robin Rowland

  • Professional
  • Kitimat, BC
  • Posts: 449
    • Robin Rowland
Re: Many happy returns
« Reply #11 on: July 09, 2012, 10:40 AM »
A few minutes after I read Warren's latest post, a friend e-mailed me a link to a collection of gorgeous photos of the old American west posted on the Daily Mail website back in May


How the Wild West REALLY looked: Gorgeous sepia-tinted pictures show the landscape as it was charted for the very first time

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2149899/The-American-West-youve-seen-Amazing-19th-century-pictures-landscape-chartered-time.html

The point is not to show off gorgeous pix (which is a plus) but the Daily Mail is (despite some of its Brit tabloid excesses) one of the most successful news websites in the world. Perhaps there's a lesson here for those who do half efforts.....


Robin Rowland
Independent visual journalist, photographer and author
Kitimat BC

http://robinrowland.com

Offline Warren Toda

  • Administrator
  • Toronto
  • Posts: 2024
    • www.warrentoda.com
    • Email
Re: Many happy returns
« Reply #12 on: July 09, 2012, 02:44 PM »
Quote from: Robin Rowland
... the Daily Mail is (despite some of its Brit tabloid excesses) one of the most successful news websites in the world. Perhaps there's a lesson here for those who do half efforts.....


Warning: long-winded rant ahead.

Notice how the Daily Mail comically added a copyright notice to these ~150 year old pictures.

The Daily Mail is well-known for altering photos and for stealing photos but, yes, it's the number one "news" site in the world. Several years ago, the National Enquirer was the highest circulation "newspaper" in North America (or was it the second  highest?).

Does this mean that papers should run more fake news, altered photos and celebrity gossip? This seems to be the trend even on respectable news sites which, until a few years ago, wouldn't be caught dead with such content.


We interrupt this rant to bring you another rant:


Maybe the lesson is that, at least online, people want to be entertained and "distracted" from daily life. It's exactly like that other medium - what's it called? - oh yeah - television.

Let's see:
TV - people sit and look at an electronic box.
Internet - people sit and look at an electronic box.

Nah, not the same thing.

Newspapers have repeatedly said for the past 12 years, "we're not competing with TV", and papers have refused to learn any of the lessons TV has learned from its 60 years of existence.

Although, if you remember back to when newspapers started their web sites in 1995-96, instead of giving their managers the usual newspaper title of "editor", they used the TV title of "producer".

I've said it before, newspapers need to fire a few of their useless web content thieves  news curators  editors and hire a programming director. Create online "channels" (news channel, comedy channel, home reno channel, etc). Yes, TV already does this but TV is not interactive. Yet.

When TV becomes interactive, newspapers will be absolutely dead. The exception is if TV executives bungle it the same way they currently bungle their web sites. Incompetence can also be a good thing.  :)

TV and newspapers don't even talk to each other. The former Canwest couldn't figure out what to do with its TV network and newspaper chain. Sun Media doesn't have a clue. Even CTV/Globe+Mail are lost. Everyone is protecting their turf, the old way of doing things.

The early mantra of "convergence!" is now dead. But sadly, that word was misinterpreted.

It was never about converging still cameras and video cameras. It was never about merging the newsroom with the web department. It was never about adding multimedia (remember that word?) to the "print" web site. It was never about cable companies buying TV networks buying newspaper chains. It was never about the tools, the corporate structure, page design or even content.

It's about converging audiences.

Remember the word "fragmented"? Audiences are fragmented, readers are fragmented.

Fragmentation is only seen when you look through the wrong end of the telescope. When viewed  correctly, audiences are, and have been for a long time, converging. It's human nature. People want to be part of something. Best example: Facebook.

Replace "convergence" with "common good". (Although newspaper executives still won't understand because they're busy trying to revive a patient that died last century).


We now return you to the Daily Mail rant, already in progress...


All newspapers, including the Daily Mail, love free content. The US Library of Congress has a zillion freeeee photos available. NASA has thousands of  freeeeee photos. Library and Archives Canada has tons of photos, as do most city archives.

Free! Free! Free!

Infinite number of stories to be had!   Infinite ways to interest newspaper readers!

Everything online!  Easy to access!  Free!  Free!

And best of all, papers can fire their expensive photographers and use all these free pictures from now on!  :D



Photographer in Toronto
info@warrentoda.com